BALTIMORE (AP) — Maryland prison officials on Wednesday withdrew proposed regulations to impose the nation’s first total ban on letters to inmates at state facilities, except for official legal correspondence and postcards.
The regulations were proposed to block inmate access to Suboxone, an addictive drug sold in thin strips that are easily concealed inside envelopes. The drug has been flooding the state’s prisons. Maryland Department of Public Safety and Correctional Services Secretary Stephen Moyer announced that a focus group would determine the best options for eliminating contraband.
“The group will also research the most effective procedures to ensure the safety of our staff and those in our custody,” the department said in a statement.
Emergency regulations to limit inmate letters to legal correspondence were proposed last month to a state legislative panel by the department, but lawmakers got pushback from the American Civil Liberties Union about the impact on inmates’ rights. The department had been planning to publish the regulations in the Maryland Register on Friday, but officials announced they were not moving forward, hours after The Associated Press exclusively reported on the proposed regulations.
The state says it intercepted more than 3,000 hits of Suboxone behind bars last year, roughly 44 percent of which were found in incoming letters. But the ACLU considers a ban on letters unconstitutional, and sent Moyer a letter Tuesday night urging him to reconsider.
“The proposal would rob families of one of the most profoundly significant forms of communication in our society,” the ACLU said. “Under the new scheme, an ailing mother could not send her son a letter for him to hold onto after she is gone. A teen could not write her mom to tell her the things she can’t say in a visit.”
The ACLU argued that the very fact that so many doses of Suboxone have been recovered from letters is a testament to the effectiveness of the current system of mail vetting.
Also, maintaining close ties to friends and family outside prison is “one of the most critical factors in a person’s success upon release,” the letter said.
On Wednesday, ACLU staff attorney Sonia Kumar said the organization is “relieved” by the state’s decision, but added that the proposal should have never been introduced.
“It’s important to also step back and look at the broader context: This is one of several policy changes that have affected families’ ability to stay in touch, and we’re gratified that the department is planning to put together a work group of some kind to look at these issues, but we think any such group has to be done with meaningful partnerships with families who can really advise the department on coming up with solutions that do the least amount of damage,” Kumar said.
While Maryland would have been the first state to enact such sweeping limitations on letters, local jurisdictions across the country have instituted similar bans. The ACLU sued the sheriff in Wilson County, Kansas, over its postcard-only policy. A Florida jail revoked its letter ban to settle a similar lawsuit.
Some state agencies have banned particular kinds of mailed material in an attempt to keep out Suboxone, which also can be soaked into certain materials. Utah in 2013 banned pictures made with crayons and markers or containing glue or stickers. Pennsylvania banned greeting cards that arrive in colored envelopes. The ACLU sued the New Hampshire prison system last year over a similar ban on greeting cards and artwork.
Teresa Hodge, co-founder of Mission: Launch Inc., a nonprofit dedicated to facilitating the re-entry of inmates into society, said her 70 months in federal prison for investment fraud would have been unbearable without letters.
“We want people to come home successful and self-sufficient and civically engaged, and part of that is staying in touch with the rest of the world and in your children’s lives,” she said. “My aunt, every other week she sent me a letter. She died soon after I was released. I still have the letters she sent me. I missed out on being able to be with her, but I have her letters.”
Hodge added that she got a job before her release because a friend’s letter described an opportunity.
“The biggest concern is, what condition will we return people in, and how will they connect post-incarceration?” Hodge said. “The fact that we’d make communicating with family, friends, support network even more challenging is really disturbing.”
Witte reported from Annapolis, Maryland.